Parser

Write an AI to parse sentences and extract noun phrases.

$ python parser.py
Sentence: Holmes sat.
        S
   _____|___
  NP        VP
  |         |
  N         V
  |         |
holmes     sat

Noun Phrase Chunks
holmes

Background

A common task in natural language processing is parsing, the process of determining the structure of a sentence. This is useful for a number of reasons: knowing the structure of a sentence can help a computer to better understand the meaning of the sentence, and it can also help the computer extract information out of a sentence. In particular, it’s often useful to extract noun phrases out of a sentence to get an understanding for what the sentence is about.

In this problem, we’ll use the context-free grammar formalism to parse English sentences to determine their structure. Recall that in a context-free grammar, we repeatedly apply rewriting rules to transform symbols into other symbols. The objective is to start with a nonterminal symbol S (representing a sentence) and repeatedly apply context-free grammar rules until we generate a complete sentence of terminal symbols (i.e., words). The rule S -> N V, for example, means that the S symbol can be rewritten as N V (a noun followed by a verb). If we also have the rule N -> "Holmes" and the rule V -> "sat", we can generate the complete sentence "Holmes sat.".

Of course, noun phrases might not always be as simple as a single word like "Holmes". We might have noun phrases like "my companion" or "a country walk" or "the day before Thursday", which require more complex rules to account for. To account for the phrase "my companion", for example, we might imagine a rule like:

NP -> N | Det N

In this rule, we say that an NP (a “noun phrase”) could be either just a noun (N) or a determiner (Det) followed by a noun, where determiners include words like "a", "the", and "my". The vertical bar (|) just indicates that there are multiple possible ways to rewrite an NP, with each possible rewrite separated by a bar.

To incorporate this rule into how we parse a sentence (S), we’ll also need to modify our S -> N V rule to allow for noun phrases (NPs) as the subject of our sentence. See how? And to account for more complex types of noun phrases, we may need to modify our grammar even further.

Getting Started

Understanding

First, look at the text files in the sentences directory. Each file contains an English sentence. Your goal in this problem is to write a parser that is able to parse all of these sentences.

Take a look now at parser.py, and notice the context free grammar rules defined at the top of the file. We’ve already defined for you a set of rules for generating terminal symbols (in the global variable TERMINALS). Notice that Adj is a nonterminal symbol that generates adjectives, Adv generates adverbs, Conj generates conjunctions, Det generates determiners, N generates nouns (spread across multiple lines for readability), P generates prepositions, and V generates verbs.

Next is the definition of NONTERMINALS, which will contain all of the context-free grammar rules for generating nonterminal symbols. Right now, there’s just a single rule: S -> N V. With just that rule, we can generate sentences like "Holmes arrived." or "He chuckled.", but not sentences more complex than that. Editing the NONTERMINALS rules so that all of the sentences can be parsed will be up to you!

Next, take a look at the main function. It first accepts a sentence as input, either from a file or via user input. The sentence is preprocessed (via the preprocess function) and then parsed according to the context-free grammar defined by the file. The resulting trees are printed out, and all of the “noun phrase chunks” (defined in the Specification) are printed as well (via the np_chunk function).

In addition to writing context-free grammar rules for parsing these sentences, the preprocess and np_chunk functions are left up to you!

Specification

Complete the implementation of preprocess and np_chunk, and complete the context-free grammar rules defined in NONTERMINALS.

  • The preprocess function should accept a sentence as input and return a lowercased list of its words.
    • You may assume that sentence will be a string.
    • You should use nltk’s word_tokenize function to perform tokenization.
    • Your function should return a list of words, where each word is a lowercased string.
    • Any word that doesn’t contain at least one alphabetic character (e.g. . or 28) should be excluded from the returned list.
  • The NONTERMINALS global variable should be replaced with a set of context-free grammar rules that, when combined with the rules in TERMINALS, allow the parsing of all sentences in the sentences/ directory.
    • Each rules must be on its own line. Each rule must include the -> characters to denote which symbol is being replaced, and may optionally include | symbols if there are multiple ways to rewrite a symbol.
    • You do not need to keep the existing rule S -> N V in your solution, but your first rule must begin with S -> since S (representing a sentence) is the starting symbol.
    • You may add as many nonterminal symbols as you would like.
    • Use the nonterminal symbol NP to represent a “noun phrase”, such as the subject of a sentence.
  • The np_chunk function should accept a tree representing the syntax of a sentence, and return a list of all of the noun phrase chunks in that sentence.
    • For this problem, a “noun phrase chunk” is defined as a noun phrase that doesn’t contain other noun phrases within it. Put more formally, a noun phrase chunk is a subtree of the original tree whose label is NP and that does not itself contain other noun phrases as subtrees.
      • For example, if "the home" is a noun phrase chunk, then "the armchair in the home" is not a noun phrase chunk, because the latter contains the former as a subtree.
    • You may assume that the input will be a nltk.tree object whose label is S (that is to say, the input will be a tree representing a sentence).
    • Your function should return a list of nltk.tree objects, where each element has the label NP.
    • You will likely find the documentation for nltk.tree helpful for identifying how to manipulate a nltk.tree object.

You should not modify anything else in parser.py other than the functions the specification calls for you to implement, though you may write additional functions and/or import other Python standard library modules. You will need to modify the definition of NONTERMINALS, but you should not modify the definition of TERMINALS.

Hints

  • It’s to be expected that your parser may generate some sentences that you believe are not syntactically or semantically well-formed. You need not worry, therefore, if your parser allows for parsing meaningless sentences like "His Thursday chuckled in a paint."
    • That said, you should avoid over-generation of sentences where possible. For example, your parser should definitely not accept sentences like "Armchair on the sat Holmes."
    • You should also avoid under-generation of sentences. A rule like S -> N V Det Adj Adj Adj N P Det N P Det N would technically successfully generate sentence 10, but not in a way that is particularly useful or generalizable.
    • The rules in the lecture source code are (intentionally) a very simplified rule set, and as a result may suffer from over-generation. You can (and should) make modifications to those rules to try to be as general as possible without over-generating. In particular, consider how you might get your parser to accept the sentence “Holmes sat in the armchair.” (and “Holmes sat in the red armchair.” and “Holmes sat in the little red armchair.”), but have it not accept the sentence “Holmes sat in the the armchair.”
  • It’s to be expected that your parser may generate multiple ways to parse a sentence. English grammar is inherently ambiguous!
  • Within the nltk.tree documentation, you may find the label and subtrees functions particularly useful.
  • To focus on testing your parser before working on noun phrase chunking, it may be helpful to temporarily have np_chunk simply return an empty list [], so that your program can operate without noun phrase chunking while you test the other parts of your program.

How to Submit

  1. Download your parser.py file (which contains your implementation of the elements of the specification of this project).
  2. Go to CSCI E-80’s Gradescope page.
  3. Click Project 6: Parser.
  4. Drag and drop your downloaded file to the area that says “Drag & Drop”. Be sure the file you’re uploading has the exact filename we are asking for, lest the autograder fail to run on it (and therefore it would receive no credit).
  5. Click Upload.

You should see a message that says “Project 6: Parser submitted successfully!” Contact your teaching fellow if not!